• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Fat Tail Daily

Investment Ideas From the Edge of the Bell Curve

  • Menu
    • Commodities
      • Resources and Mining
      • Copper
      • Gold
      • Iron Ore
      • Lithium
      • Silver
      • Graphite
      • Rare Earths
    • Technology
      • AI
      • Bitcoin
      • Cryptocurrency
      • Energy
      • Financial Technology
      • Bio Technology
    • Market Analysis
      • Latest ASX News
      • Dividend Shares
      • ETFs
      • Stocks and Bonds
    • Macro
      • Australian Economy
      • Central Banks
      • World Markets
    • Small Caps
    • More
      • Investment Guides
      • Premium Research
      • Editors
      • About
      • Contact Us
  • Latest
  • Fat Tail Series
  • About Us
Latest

Don’t Trust This Bullshit Rally | What’s Not Priced In

Like 0

By Kiryll Prakapenka, Friday, 08 December 2023

Stocks up. Mood up. But is it all BS?

In today’s Fat Tail Daily, this is a bullshit rally. So said Greg Canavan in an internal group chat. To him, the recent melt-up makes little sense. Tune in to this week’s episode of What’s Not Priced In for more on this, as well as Greg’s ‘lower and sooner’ September call, and the latest big moves in gold, bitcoin and key commodities. Enjoy…

This is a bullshit rally.

So said Greg Canavan in an internal group chat.

Gruff, blunt, direct.

To him, the recent melt-up makes little sense.

The ASX 200 recording its biggest one-day gain in a year following weak GDP figures only confirmed Greg’s suspicions.

Real GDP per capita growth is negative year on year.

Households saved only 1% of their income in the September quarter.

And more of our disposable income is going to taxes than it has in years.

Market saw all this, shrugged, then bid stocks higher.

Some may be revelling in the Santa rally (like my colleague Callum Newman). Cal’s long said pessimism is misplaced.

But not Greg.

Like the Grinch, he doesn’t buy the festive exuberance. More on that in a bit.

But first, in this jam-packed episode of What’s Not Priced In, Greg and I covered:

  • Dubious nature of recent stock rally
  • Market’s new rate narrative: but is a soft landing really the most likely outcome?
  • Greg’s ‘lower and sooner’ September call
  • Big moves in gold and Bitcoin
  • Is gold looking to march higher from here as real rates fall?
  • Is appetite for riskier assets growing?
  • Lithium stocks and the EV adoption paradox
  • Are coal stocks cheap?
  • Washington Soul Pattinson’s bid for Perpetual a sign of emerging value on ASX

Markets and narratives

Markets abhor a narrative vacuum.

Events quickly beget explanations. Whether an explanation is accurate often matters less than the fact an explanation exists.

The 24/7 news cycle worsens this.

Journalists feel pressured to contextualise daily fluctuations in stocks or tiny changes in yields.

Market commentators feel pressured to give smart answers to the same gyrations.

Everyone feels pressured to reach for the popular narrative.

Easier to parrot the prevailing explanation than stick your neck out.

Better the collective failure than individual embarrassment.

If the narrative proves false, no matter. Since everyone espoused it, no one was really wrong. It was simply a surprise, a shock, not an error.

With the Internet, narratives now run at hyper speed. They coalesce quickly…and collapse just as fast.

Look at how the ‘higher for longer’ theme is playing out.

It was the explanation du jour a few months ago. Bonds plummeted. Yields soared.

Now markets are all about rate cuts.

The CNN Fear and Greed index was at extreme fear at the start of November. It’s now flashing greed.

Not even the fashion industry has a turnover this quick.

CNN Fear and Greed index

Source: CNN

[Click to open in a new window]

Revisiting September

Consider our mid-September episode.

There, Greg argued the ‘higher for longer’ narrative will change to ‘lower and sooner’ as markets catch on to the economic reality.

Greg said (my paraphrase):

‘If I’m right about this — lack of fiscal stimulus, tight monetary policy and its lagged impacts — it will send inflation lower. And it will force central banks like the Fed to cut sooner than the market currently thinks. So the ‘higher for longer’ crowd will realise rates have to come down, and quickly. We’re at mid-September now. Let’s give it 2–3 months and see whether that view starts to shift. Because these things do take time.

‘But that would be one non-consensus that I think people should begin considering. How to take advantage? Look at gold. Gold often moves in ways opposite to real interest rates … Gold’s in a bit of a stealth bull market … No one’s really interest in gold at the moment, you hardly hear about it.’

The view did shift (and gold did move).

But it didn’t take time. And it shifted for different reasons.

Greg thought consensus would switch because of predicted economic weakness. It switched because of a predicted soft landing.

Consider this.

Last month, Goldman Sachs’s US financial conditions index recorded its biggest monthly drop in four decades.

Benign disinflation

Recently, I came across a good book by James Valentine.

In it, Valentine wrote how investors go wrong by focusing on immaterial factors. Factors that don’t move the needle.

He had a great table summarising how investors can mistake irrelevant factors for critical ones:

investors can mistake irrelevant factors for critical ones

Source: Valentine

[Click to open in a new window]

Now, let’s do an exercise along these lines.

The market currently believes lower interest rates are coming soon and this is good for stocks.

This is true if disinflation is benign and the economy remains resilient.

This is not true if interest rates fall because the economy is deteriorating. This is not true either if inflation remains sticky, prolonging tight monetary policy.

As Greg said, quicker than expected rate cuts follow worse than expected economic performance.

The market is positioning for rate cuts and growth. For instance, consensus forecasts have S&P500 earnings lifting 11%, with the benchmark US index trading at 18.6x those earnings.

But can you really have rate cuts and growth?

Watch the episode for the answer.

In the meantime,beware the bullshit rally.

PS: In the countdown to Christmas, Fat Tail’s awesome design team mocked up Fat Tail’s version of an advent calendar. Today was my turn. Keep sending your questions, and maybe I’ll keep wearing hats!

Fat Tail Investment Research

[Click to open in a new window]

Regards,

Kiryll Prakapenka Signature

Kiryll Prakapenka is a research analyst with a passion and focus on investigating the big trends in the investment market. Kiryll brings sound analytical skills to his work, courtesy of his Philosophy degree from the University of Melbourne. A student of legendary investors and their strategies, Kiryll likes to synthesise macroeconomic narratives with a keen understanding of the fundamentals behind companies. He’s the host of our weekly podcast What’s Not Priced In where he and a new guest week figure out the story (and risks and opportunities) the market is missing to give you an advantage. Follow via your preferred channel and check it out!

All advice is general advice and has not taken into account your personal circumstances.

Please seek independent financial advice regarding your own situation, or if in doubt about the suitability of an investment.

Comments

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Kiryll Prakapenka

Kiryll’s Premium Subscriptions

Publication logo
Fat Tail Investment Research

Latest Articles

  • OpenAI and Microsoft Divorce?: Why this could be good for you
    By Charlie Ormond

    While breakups are rarely pretty, this one might actually benefit investors willing to look beyond the drama.

  • Three Lithium Stocks in the Buy Zone
    By Murray Dawes

    Lithium stocks jumped this week, so Murray and Callum discuss whether this could be the beginning of the second boom in lithium stocks. They also discuss a fund manager that is recovering and looking cheap

  • Every Australian Investor Has a Stake in Mining
    By James Cooper

    With its deep pool of retirement capital, Australia is on track to become the world’s primary destination for resource markets.

Primary Sidebar

Latest Articles

  • OpenAI and Microsoft Divorce?: Why this could be good for you
  • Three Lithium Stocks in the Buy Zone
  • Every Australian Investor Has a Stake in Mining
  • The next wave of AI winners
  • Could the US People Repudiate the National Debt?

Footer

Fat Tail Daily Logo
YouTube
Facebook
x (formally twitter)
LinkedIn

About

Investment ideas from the edge of the bell curve.

Go beyond conventional investing strategies with unique ideas and actionable opportunities. Our expert editors deliver conviction-led insights to guide your financial journey.

Quick Links

Subscribe

About

FAQ

Terms and Conditions

Financial Services Guide

Privacy Policy

Get in Touch

Contact Us

Email: support@fattail.com.au

Phone: 1300 667 481

All advice is general in nature and has not taken into account your personal circumstances. Please seek independent financial advice regarding your own situation, or if in doubt about the suitability of an investment.

The value of any investment and the income derived from it can go down as well as up. Never invest more than you can afford to lose and keep in mind the ultimate risk is that you can lose whatever you’ve invested. While useful for detecting patterns, the past is not a guide to future performance. Some figures contained in our reports are forecasts and may not be a reliable indicator of future results. Any actual or potential gains in these reports may not include taxes, brokerage commissions, or associated fees.

Fat Tail Logo

Fat Tail Daily is brought to you by the team at Fat Tail Investment Research

Copyright © 2025 Fat Tail Daily | ACN: 117 765 009 / ABN: 33 117 765 009 / ASFL: 323 988